Friday, January 7, 2011

Still Thinking about The Things They Carried

How can it be that so many people can enjoy and even relate to the same story and yet come from very different times, places, positions and backrounds?

Monday, January 3, 2011

Thinking about The Things They Carried

So here's what I've been thinking...
I decided to include Tim O'Brien's "The Things They Carried" as a required text for our class so that we could each participate in a larger book discussion as well as take advantage of having the author visit during GetLit! And I thought blogging might give us all a different experience. Remember that postings should be short, conversational, and worthwhile.

So, have to I admit that I've had some reservations; the book has some pretty violent and graphic scenes (I've already listened to it on cd), but my husband assures me that even an eighth grader could manage this.
I don't know;  Gary, my husband, is a Viet Nam vet so his perspective may be somewhat colored by his experience.

Yet...don't we all come to a text from our own history? And given that, how can there be unequivocal right and wrong answers about a story unless we trivialize the learning that storytelling brings to us by debasing the knowing to the simplest and most sanitary level of recall?

I sometimes wonder whether two people can ever be reading the same story even as they read the same text...

Thoughts?